Wednesday, August 14, 2013

Today's Mobile Banking Apps: Table Stakes or Cutting Edge

There is no disputing that the U.S. mobile banking landscape is changing rapidly. Larger banks are setting the stage for broader market trends, while smaller banks (and even some regional players) play catch up in the development of new functionality.

What are some of the top U.S. banks doing that is innovative and what has quickly become table stakes in a game of mobile app one-upsmanship? And is mobile banking innovation becoming a value-added differentiator that can drive new revenues?

Over the past 18 months, mobile banking applications have evolved beyond the basics to include specialized functionalities, improved user experiences and an expansion of platforms supported. A year ago, mobile remote deposit capture (RDC) was live at only five of the top 13 banks. Today, it is a 'must have' banking application that has the potential to drive revenue. Similarly, P2P is now taking center stage at most banks despite some logistical hurdles, with five banks adding this functionality in the past 12 months.

How are banks keeping up with consumer demands? How are they keeping up with each other? What's next? In the third report in a series on the state of mobile banking released by the financial research and consulting firm Celent, a review of new application development is provided along with a glimpse into the future. 

In the 44-page report, The U.S. Mobile App Landscape: An Annual Evaluation of Mobile Banking at Top U.S. Banks, Celent found that larger banks tend to out-develop and out-adopt smaller institutions by a significant margin. “The channel is still relatively new, but leaders in the digital channel space are beginning to take offerings into the realm of value-added services that are context-sensitive, timely, and utilize big data", says Dan Latimore, senior vice president of Celent's Banking Group and coauthor of the report. "There’s a large disparity among digital offerings—industry leaders are light-years ahead of the laggards.”

Below is Celent's view of the mobile landscape as it continues to evolve. As can be seen, Emerging Capabilities include a more advanced stage of interaction with more knowledge-driven tools and analytics. While some of these may not be pursued by every organization, Celent believes most will be tomorrow's standard. Interestingly, some of the functionality in the Future Focus is already being implemented on a global basis (see previous post 'Banks Accelerate Mobile Banking Innovation', June 2013). 

While the future may be considered speculative, some components are beginning to appear at the more progressive institutions (U.S. Bank and BBVA Photo Bill Pay) and at some of the new players such as Moven, Simple, GoBank and BlueBird (see 'Challenger Brands & Disruptive Ideas: Learning From The NeoBanks', Financial Brand, August 2013).

Current Evolution of Mobile (Celent, June 2013)

Key Findings of the report include:
      • Mobile, and more broadly digital channels, have become core parts of banking in 2013. Mobile devices are now just as much a tool to keep people out of branches as they are to facilitate interaction. Consumers are more eager to engage through a smartphone, and as nontraditional players rush in to fill gaps left by legacy financial institutions, CIOs are beginning to feel the pressure to build out digital capabilities.
      • Digital channels are in a continuous process of evolution, proliferation, and adaption. While remote deposit capture was 'new' a year ago, it is now a basic functionality. Innovation in the mobile channels is ongoing with today's innovations quickly becoming tomorrow's table stakes. 
      • Banks are moving forward in their evolution of digital channels, but it's a slow and sometimes confusing process. It’s no surprise that banks aren’t considered innovators: it’s difficult, expensive, and risky to innovate. Yet, banking is entering a time of customer-centricity, where each institution defines this concept differently.
      • New functionality is on the horizon, but not yet front and center. This includes: 1) Speech recognition, 2) Social media integration, 3) Mobile PFM tools, 4) Easy access account balance, 5) Cardless cash withdrawal, 6) Debit card on/off switch, 7) Remote mobile bill pay, and 8) Biometric security.

How Are The Top Banks Doing?

Mobile is definitely moving beyond the replication of online banking services and into value-added features built to serve more specific use cases and even different segments of the bank (retail consumer, small business, wealth management, commercial, etc.). As shown above, the evolution is trending towards an environment where solutions are being 'bought' vs. 'built' and where engagement of the customer on a contextual level is beginning to be achieved. 

Using a features and functionality scoring sheet for each mobile platform (developed as part of the previous Celent research 'What's App, Doc: A Biannual Evaluation of Mobile Banking at Top U.S. Banks'), Celent evaluated apps for the Apple iOS, Android, Safari web browser and text banking. Scores were compiled for the top 13 banks in the U.S., with banks grouped into three categories based on the following criteria:
            • How easy was it to find the desired function?
            • How easy was the app to use?
            • Was the information presented intuitive from a navigation perspective?
            • Did the app take advantage of standard OS functionality to enhance familiarity?

A very in-depth evaluation was performed for the following functions on each mobile platform to determine breadth of offering. Each function was evaluated on a number of levels with values placed on each of the following capabilities: 
            • Balance inquiry
            • Recap of previous transactions
            • Bill payments
            • Moving money (RDC, A2A, P2P, etc.)
            • Merchant-funded rewards
            • PFM tools
            • Social Media integration
            • Geolocational tools
            • Marketing and sales
            • Security
            • Customer support
            • Personalization
            • Alerts

Celent grouped the banks in this report into the following three categories: most improved, noticeable improvements, and minimal/ no changes.
        1. The most improved apps include Bank of America and US Bank.
        2. Apps with noticeable improvements are Capital One, Wells Fargo, and HSBC.
        3. Banks with minimal or no changes to their mobile offerings include BB&T, Chase, Citibank, Fifth ThirdPNCRegions BankSunTrust and TD Bank.

According to Dan Latimore, "While Chase continues to build on their mobile excellence, some apps have been playing catch up." And while not making significant changes does not necessarily mean the mobile banking site was poor, standing still in today's mobile marketplace is not a solid long-term strategy.

Interestingly, in an unrelated research study conducted by Xtreme Labs for the period May 18 - June 1, 2013, entitled 'U.S. Banking Apps Report: Customer Reviews', a different set of 'winners' emerged based simply on the number of positive and negative customer ratings in both the Apple iTunes Store and Android Play Store. A minimum number of reviews were required for any app and an averaging of reviews was used for scaling. While significantly less scientific than the Celent research, the Xtreme Labs research provides a social media commentary on customer sentiment around mobile banking apps.

Of the largest banks reviewed by Xtreme Labs, RBS Citizens, had the highest score on the iOS platform (4.5 out of 5 and a 93% favorability rating) and one of the best scores on the Android platform (4.5 out of 5 and a 97% favorability rating). USAA, American Express, Wells, TD Bank, Chase, BB&T and Regions and U.S. Bank also scored well in this study.

Conversely, PNC (not virtual wallet), SunTrust, TD Bank, Fifth Third, Bank of America, Well Fargo and USAA also appeared on the negative side for the iOS platform in the Xtreme Lab study, indicating that the mobile apps were not considered the best for everyone.

Issues to Address in Future

Beyond the need to explore the development of additional functionality that makes engagement easier and leverages big data more effectively, Celent saw some trends they believed warrant attention in the near term.

Marketing and Cross-Selling

As was noted in my June 2013 blog post around Mapa Research's study of global mobile banking innovation, U.S. mobile banking apps still haven't leveraged some of the power of cross-selling from a mobile device. While the Celent research noted that many banks have attempted some form of 'product pushing' or advertising of services, there seems to be minimal leveraging of big data insights to drive contextual offers. "Splash screens and real estate crowding banner ads should be left to online banking", say Latimore. "Apps should move toward offering up product suggestions (without sacrificing user experience) as well as being able to facilitate the beginning of an enrollment process, which can be finished at the branch, over the phone or online".


While it is understandable that many banks may be a bit skittish around using Apple Maps for branch and/or ATM directions given early flaws with the iOS application, using Google Maps from within the Safari browser was found to be slow and 'clunky' compared to the integrated option from Apple. Celent believes the risk may be worth it. Another option (used by both PNC Bank and U.S. Bank) may be the use of augmented reality for locational guides.

App Design and Platform Changes

Celent noticed that a number of apps in the study had little or no change from the previous report from Q4 2012. While this may not seem out of the ordinary if compared to bank website redesigns, and certainly falls in line with the industry's normal 'wait and see' approach, this speed of change is not acceptable to most mobile users who are used to constant and frequent enhancements to apps.

In addition, as tablets of all forms have exploded onto the marketplace, banks have done a terrible job of developing applications that take advantage of this very unique platform. Beyond the tactile and length of engagement differentiation of this platform, the demographics of the typical user (more affluent and more digitally astute) warrants a greater focus.

PFM on Mobile

There is no disputing that PFM on mobile has yet to gain any traction. Banks are struggling to define what PFM should be and what it should look like on different channels as well as platforms. The majority of consumers are not attracted to charts and graphs on mobile devices (there is a segment however). But PFM on mobile may provide promise if looked at in the perspective of improved receipts, budget updates and even gamification. Merchant-funded reward integration is also possible with geolocational capabilities providing the ability for immediate rewards through the mobile device.

While some banks are testing some of these capabilities (most notably the neobanks like Moven as covered here in my early 2013 blog post), there is quite a bit of debate on whether the investment in development can be recouped without a value-added pricing model.

According to Latimore, "Eventually, Celent imagines high-value advice on savings, alerts for overspending on a budget category, or GPS-enabled deals. The camera is another unique attribute to the mobile phone that can be used to provide a snapshot of spending."

The Long Road Ahead

Mobile banking has quickly evolved from being a more cost effective way to handle balance inquiries to a core component of every bank's delivery network. We have moved from a transaction focus to an engagement focus, with CIOs beginning to feel the pressure to build out mobile capabilities. 

With basic mobile transactions such as balance inquiry and moving money, simplicity is the 'new black'. With more sophisticated interactions, the use of 'big data' for insight dissemination and solution recommendations is the key to success. In all cases, Celent found a trend away from 'bolt-on modules' to more holistic approaches that will require significant investment.

While other industries have reached young adulthood in mobile integration, mobile banking is still in its infancy. With shrinking margins and more regulatory pressure, banks must determine if there is the potential for mobile services to generate revenue that can help offset development costs and replace lost fee income. Without fees from new value added services, what is the ROI of mobile banking? (see previous BMS post, 'The Revenue Power of Emerging Financial Solutions", August 2013)

According to Celent's Dan Latimore, "While mobile banking definitely expands a bank's ability to reach new and existing customers, and while there is significant movement by some organizations, there is still a long road ahead for others."

About the Report

The report reviewed is the third in Celent’s series on the state of mobile banking at top US financial institutions. The report examines mobile application offerings at the top 13 US banks in significant detail, beginning by looking at the state of the mobile market in the US. Celent graphically explains trends in mobile, and tries to make a case for what the future of mobile will look like. The report then dives deeply into the breadth of functionality and usability at each of these banks. Finally, each bank’s mobile application is profiled in depth, with accompanying screen shots to illustrate relevant points. This report is the best of its kind and is intended to serve as a guideline for conversations around how to strategically align mobile development with prevailing best practices.

A webinar on this study in conjunction with Kony, entitled, Tomorrow's Mobile Banking - Hear What Top U.S. Banks are Doing to Get a Glimpse Into the Crystal Ball is scheduled for September 11, 2013 at 2PM ET. 

Additional Resources

The U.S. Mobile App Landscape: An Annual Evaluation of Mobile Banking at Top U.S. Banks - Celent (June 2013)

Mobile Banker Vendor Solutions - Celent (April 2013)

What's App, Doc: An Updated Biannual Evaluation of Mobile Banking at Top U.S. Banks - Celent (January 2013)

U.S. Banking Apps Report: Customer Reviews - Xtreme Labs (July 2013)

Tomorrow's Mobile Banking - Hear What Top U.S. Banks are Doing to Get a Glimpse Into the Crystal Ball - American Banker Webinar sponsored by Kony (September 11, 2013)

Mobile in 2013: A Digital Digest Featuring Gartner Research - Kony (March 2013)

Subscribe to Bank Marketing Strategy Via Email


  1. Great post, Jim. You are right, PFM has a long way to go as a "product". At it's best version, all banking is "personal financial management", and mobile will continue to be a core requirement.

  2. Right on the spot! Mobile banking trends indeed drive new revenues to both companies and banks itself. As such consumer impression on mobile banking must be changed as large numbers of them don't really trust the method. Accelerating amounts of data is a somewhat a large factor in the near future that can be addressed today by the devs.